Outside the marginals

A commentary on the politics that followed the UK 2010, 2015 & 2017 elections

President Gideon and Lame Duck Dave

Listening to our future leader on the Andrew Marr Show (BBC1 22 November 2015) it strikes me that we (the UK) have a very odd national political leadership.

The Chancellor is becoming increasingly Presidential speaking on all sorts of matters and appearing in photo-opportunities such as in GCHQ and in various provinces as “their leaders” sign up to his preferred mayoral (presidential) form of local government.

The Prime Minister seems to be increasingly irrelevant as he puts his remaining energies into his final tilt at the European windmill.

Is this just an extreme version of the always difficult relationship between the Prime Minister and “his chancellor”? I think not.

Even though Gideon’s attempts to fund his tax give-ways (Inheritance Tax on “family homes”, reduced Corporation Tax etc.) from “cracking down” on the “working poor” has been temporarily stymied, he still seems to be exercising a relatively unrestrained mandate.

Under the cloak of the “Northern Powerhouse” he is imposing  on “City Regions” a form of government that has been widely rejected. Mayors have been rejected almost everywhere when put to referenda. “City regions” while possibly obvious in terms of metropolitan areas like Greater Manchester, in areas like the North East (of England) which includes the huge rural areas of Northumberland and Durham stretches the definition of “city”.

Necessity is meant to be the reason; without “strong mayors” the Northern Powerhouse will not work – we are told.

But the Northern Powerhouse requires more than a “strong man” – Newcastle tried that in the 1960s when an over-powerful council leader (not even a Gideonian Mayor) pushed through huge changes but at a cost to the reputation on good governance. The Powerhouse needs an overarching vision and a structure to get “the great cities” (at a minimum Liverpool, Manchester and Leeds) to work together – initially with Government support (i.e. taxpayers’ money) to create an alternative economic centre to the country which can break the dependence of the North (of England) on exchequer support.

Yet we have seen the “Northern Electrification” of the conventional railway between Leeds and Manchester delayed – not by HS2 style debate – but good old fashioned Whitehall “book balancing” (contrast with Cross-Rail and the Great Western Electrification).

We have seen the Government stand back as the steel industry has taken a pounding – in effect saying “we can’t do anything – the combined forces of globalisation and EU regulation prevent us from acting” (despite other European Countries finding ways to support their steel industries).

So is Gideon’s Northern Powerhouse actually intended to be a new economic engine – or is it a cloak to devolve the problem (and costs) of regeneration back onto the various parts of the North? Will we in the future hear Westminster and Whitehall saying “don’t blame us for the cuts, blame your mayors – you elected them”?

Mayoral Government is essentially binary – even with a better voting system, electing one person means that you don’t get consensus, you get “rule by the least unpopular” – which in most city regions is likely to be perpetual Labour with very occasional outbursts of various “independent” Conservatives. Power will be concentrated not in council committee rooms but in (Labour) party selection committees.

Whilst it may be thought to go against the Conservative desire to take power and rule where-ever and when-ever possible, such a system suits Conservatives like Gideon. Binary-ism suits him – it reduces all fights to a fight between two dogs one of which is Conservative. This has two advantages.

He knows that binary-ism inhibits genuine political innovation – A Green Mayor of one of these City regions is almost as unthinkable as a Liberal Mayor. With power concentrated in the Mayor’s parlour, Greens, Liberals, UKIPpers and other “disruptives” in committee rooms are powerless and – more importantly – pointless. Through the monopoly nature of mayoral (or presidential) power, it also tends to inhibit change until there is a political earthquake. (The London Mayor is not a good comparison because London is far more balanced politically between Left and Right than the Northern City Regions.)

He also knows that in many parts of the country Conservatives cannot win until Labour is thoroughly discredited.  And what better way of doing this than a system of Labour Mayors ruling big city regions which fail due to lack of funding, lack of vision and local infighting?

Gideon is a raw politician – much of what he does, when stripped back, is for short-term naked political benefit. He is very good at it. His tactics have as good as destroyed the Liberal Democrats for at least a generation.

The problem is that sort of politician – even in some highly dysfunctional republics – is not the sort of politician who should hold presidential, let alone prime ministerial office.


Single Post Navigation

One thought on “President Gideon and Lame Duck Dave

  1. The Northern Powerhouse concept is certainly becoming more obvious in southern Lancashire. In effect, the towns that originally made this country great during the industrial revolution, such as Bolton and Wigan, are slowly being drained of resources and facilities in order to glamorise Manchester. They will soon be no more than ‘dormitories’ with town centres devoid of any quality shops, and those remaining will mainly be run by immigrants, with evening entertainment consisting almost exclusively of noisy bars providing cannon fodder for the local A&E departments (which will no doubt also end up in Manchester).

    The new electrified rail routes with their longer (southern cast-off) trains will soon be overwhelmed during rush hour as more and more people are forced into working in Manchester. The evening rush hour will be extended especially at weekends, as even more of the entertainment in terms of theatre, restaurants and music is relocated to Manchester, and the taxi firms will be rubbing their hands with glee when everyone has to make struggle home due to the woefully inadequate evening public transport.

    There will be no significant regional shift in power, just a local one.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: